Traditional Coquito Recipe Ingredients 2-15 oz can of cream of coconut (I prefer Coco Lopez) 1 quart eggnog (store-bought or your favorite recipe) 1-12oz can of evaporated milk 6 cinnamon sticks 1 cup of sugar 6 egg yolks, (discard the whites) ½ a fifth of dark … [Read more...] about Coquito Recipe Puerto Rican Style